Not all humans inherently deserve rights just because they are human. Think of people like Hiter, Jeffrey Dahmer, and the dozens of other evil people. No one would reasonably think they deserve sympathy, because of what they chose to do.

If your evil enough to commit such a heinous act as child rape, I don’t see any legitimate reason why that person should deserve any sort of sympathy.

Subconsciously everyone agrees on this to some extent. Look at prisons, (depending on the crime) they remove your right to vote, own a gun, even walk outside, and have certain jobs.

The reason I believed my take is controversial is because of how I think those pedos would lose their rights. I believe people as evil as them aren’t people at all. They are simply containers of flesh with a human face, and should be seen as such. I have no issue with the idea they should be used as slaves and test subjects. Arguably this would actually benefit humanity (especially in terms of medicine) because now instead of risking the lives of innocent people like doctors or everyday Joe’s, we could use them to see if the experimental drug has any side effects. Honestly, what are they going to do? Revoke consent? I wonder of the child they raped got that same privilege…

I’m sure this goes without saying but the person would have to be caught red-handed with undeniable proof to be subjected to this

  • Schwim Dandy@lemm.eeEnglish
    11·
    6 months ago

    It’s your last sentence that perfectly points out the flaw in your logic. There will always be variations on your “perfect pedo” that you’ve created in your head that would warrant some consideration regarding punishments and rights.

    Being a person that was molested as a child, I find you just choosing one type of predator absurd and dismissive of every other victim that doesn’t fall into your “special victim” classification. I don’t think the person that offended against me was any worse or better than someone that did it to an adult or committed elder abuse, etc.

    • BezzelBob@lemmy.worldOPEnglish
      19·
      6 months ago

      There will always be variations on your “perfect pedo” that you’ve created in your head that would warrant some consideration regarding punishments and rights.

      Well yes, this is all a hypothetical, I’m not a lawyer or going to write a whole 300 page bill on the ins and outs so yes there’s some assumptions that need to be made

      I find you just choosing one type of predator absurd and dismissive of every other victim that doesn’t fall into your “special victim” classification.

      I wasn’t dismissing other victims all rape is evil and abhorrent, but rape against a child who’s brain isn’t developed and doesnt have a strong foundation of the world is especially cruel

      • Schwim Dandy@lemm.eeEnglish
        3·
        6 months ago

        I wasn’t dismissing other victims all rape is evil and abhorrent, but rape against a child who’s brain isn’t developed and doesnt have a strong foundation of the world is especially cruel

        I disagree with you there. It’s all equally cruel. In my case, my young age allowed me to recover from something that perhaps I wouldn’t have as an adult. If it had to happen, I’m glad it happened at the age(8ish or so) that it did.

        • Maeve@kbin.social
          2·
          6 months ago

          Thank you for being so open and honest. A family member was also a victim of CSA at an early age. They sound a lot like op, today. I’m so glad you were able to get past it, and so openly share. You’ve done a lot of work. A lot of work. I’m so impressed.

        • BezzelBob@lemmy.worldOPEnglish
          32·
          6 months ago

          I’m glad you were able to recover, and I’m genuinely sorry you had to go through that

          Your right, maybe it’s all equally evil