• Numberone@startrek.website
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    0
    ·
    1 year ago

    Yeah, this argument is getting at what’s underlying my concern I think. There is a huge vacuum of trustworthy authority right now. It seems like institutions have been lighting themselves on fire left and right. This may be a problem that simply comes from the existence of the internet. 50 years ago everyone just trusted that Walter Cronkite was telling them the truth every evening, he was a big arbiter, likely because they didn’t have any other sources of information the internet makes available. He may have been acting in good faith, he may have been parroting defense department talking points, who knows. Now we have a website to cater to every intellectual pretaliction. That isn’t helpful to find definitive truth. Add to that, over and over we’ve found existing authorities to be completely self serving (e.g. the government lying about WMD in Iraq, CDC obfuscating it’s funding of gain of function research early in the pandemic, recent revelations of perhaps long running corruption concern in the supreme court). Maybe that’s because they’ve gotten worse, maybe they’ve always been like that and we didn’t have enough information to notice it. So, like you said, all of this is happening and we no longer have arbiters to sift out this wheat from the chaff as it were. That’s a huge problem.

    So what’s the solution? I certainly don’t want Republicans to be removing books from their shelves because they deem them “harmful to the children” or whatever the fuck. But at the same time, I don’t want self serving billionaires (the shitshow that twitter has become) or newly revealed corrupt institutions making those decisions for me either. So what’s the solution?

    I think right now it’s basically an unsolved problem, with all of us just floating around to the sources that suit us best, allowing for the divides between us to absolutely explode in breadth and width (I have family that has strait faced told me that COVID was created and released on purpose to kill Republicans…shit like that). I know that I’ve struggled with who to “trust” consciously. And maybe that’s the real difference between our perspectives is just that. Maybe that’s what this all comes down to is that you don’t trust American right wing institutions (rightfully) and I’ve lost faith in all of them. I don’t know what the move is, but we need to figure something out fast.

    • Chetzemoka@kbin.social
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      0
      ·
      1 year ago

      The deluge of information is definitely a problem, and it’s a problem that is exploited by bad actors (see: “firehose of falsehood” tactic explicitly endorsed by Russian intelligence that was used to great effect by Trump during his time as president)

      I think A solution for the time being (perhaps not THE solution ultimately, but for now) is to adhere to quality evidence based whenever possible, which is something we definitely can review for ourselves. Vet and re-vet individual sources to determine which ones we can trust. And beyond that, go with a consensus. There will always be that one expert who disagrees with the majority on any issue no matter what, but if the general consensus is in a certain direction, then that’s the way we should try to go

      • Numberone@startrek.website
        link
        fedilink
        arrow-up
        0
        ·
        1 year ago

        Yeah, I guess that’s just more responsibility on us as individuals…hurray -_-

        Thanks for engaging with me on this, I feel like it did clarify some things in my mind just having to justify myself. I appreciate. I hope I see you out there again Beltalowda.🖖