• 2 Posts
  • 1.71K Comments
Joined 1 year ago
cake
Cake day: June 16th, 2023

help-circle

  • I would like you to explain how Captain America and Superman are reactionary.

    I mean… c’mon. Captain America is low-hanging fruit - the correlation between Captain America and actual US behavior in the world essentially writes itself.

    Superman is a far more sophisticated representation of US-style liberalism - but, just like liberalism itself, that doesn’t make Super Cheese any less of a reactionary.

    However… we can talk about the individual politics of these characters all day long - and we’d be missing the entire point of the metaphor in it’s entirety.

    The problem with the “super hero” genre is not the individual politics of the characters concerned - it’s with how they normalize and justify the concentration of power in the hands of these exalted individuals.

    In other words - the problem is fundamental.

    He doesn’t understand the core themes of superheroes,

    I think he understand them perfectly, because…

    Zack Snyder is an Objectivist



  • but student terrorist movements were largely left behind in the 70s

    The left has never left the use of force in the past - it is as available to us today, and as thoroughly justified, as it was in the 70’s… 1570s, 1870s or 2070s.

    The willingness to use force doesn’t distinguish between a left and a (supposed) “far left” - the left is not a mirror of the right, and there is no leftist equivalent to a far right (which is purely distinguished by it’s proximity to, willingness to control and/or operate the state machinery of violence).

    It’s not about spots on a silly “political compass” infographic and never has been.


  • By American standards, the Stop Cop City people are a ‘far left’ group;

    That’s not “far left.” That’s just plain old bog-standard left - whether in the US or anywhere else.

    action against Stop Cop City has been pretty brutal.

    Again… just common-or-garden variety treatment the left has always received from the forces of the status quo - nothing “far left” about it.

    There’s no such thing as a “far left” - and it’s critical that we push back on these kinds of propagandistic framing devices liberals love to use to demonize the left and provide cover for the right. I don’t think leftists realize how powerful and dangerous this basic type of propaganda can be.