Not that incorrect. Sure, it’ll select from 15 different plants, 8 different creatures, and a handful of ground textures, but they’re functionally the same unless you’re building an outpost. There’s really not anything I can do on one planet I can’t do on another.
What I mean is that you’re correct, but only in terms of randomly generated planets that don’t have unique quest content or locations on them, which does exist, so not “every single planet is the exact same with minor cosmetic differences”. Even the generated planets differ in mineral content and such.
I’m all for calling out Starfield where it deserves it, and variety of generated planets is one such place, but try not to be too over exaggerated and hyperbolic, there’s enough to genuinely criticize that we don’t need to do that.
It’s more that the difference between unique quest locations and city planets is being swept under the rug in order to just dunk harder on the game. It dunks hard enough on itself, I fundamentally dislike such blatant, hyperbolic misinformation, so I’m gonna be the change I wanna see in the world and call it out. Shit, the OP of the comment even admitted it was incorrect, just “not that” incorrect.
Obviously the cities arent procedural. But thats not something to hail and praise, thats just normal. Its no more swept under the rug than “at least the guns shoot bullets at the enemies, and eventually it makes them die” is being swept under.
I’m just glad it’s been acknowledged now, so that people who aren’t us that can say “obviously” know that there’s more to it and it’s not “every single planet is exactly the same”.
The cities arent planets, as advertised for planetary exploration. Theyre cities. Preset prebuilt themed hubs meant for main quest check boxes and 2-5 side quests, with merchants.
When people say skyrim is filled with shit to do and explore, they dont mean “wowie zowie, those cities sure were designed by hand!” They mean that when they walk from the city to the quest waypoint, they bump into 50 different things to fuck around and do, and each is different and unique enough that it felt like you had 50 different things to do. And thats with the free criticism that skyrims dungeons were mildly samey and formulaic.
There isnt more to it. A technicality of the hub regions being on a planetary body doesnt change that the planets are all the same procedurally shuffled boxes.
Ocean wide, puddle deep. Every single planet is the exact same with only minor cosmetic differences.
Holy vague, sweeping, definitively incorrect generalization, Batman.
Not that incorrect. Sure, it’ll select from 15 different plants, 8 different creatures, and a handful of ground textures, but they’re functionally the same unless you’re building an outpost. There’s really not anything I can do on one planet I can’t do on another.
What I mean is that you’re correct, but only in terms of randomly generated planets that don’t have unique quest content or locations on them, which does exist, so not “every single planet is the exact same with minor cosmetic differences”. Even the generated planets differ in mineral content and such.
I’m all for calling out Starfield where it deserves it, and variety of generated planets is one such place, but try not to be too over exaggerated and hyperbolic, there’s enough to genuinely criticize that we don’t need to do that.
Kinda odd youre kibitzing over completely deserved criticism because you can kind of nitpick about mineral deposits.
It’s more that the difference between unique quest locations and city planets is being swept under the rug in order to just dunk harder on the game. It dunks hard enough on itself, I fundamentally dislike such blatant, hyperbolic misinformation, so I’m gonna be the change I wanna see in the world and call it out. Shit, the OP of the comment even admitted it was incorrect, just “not that” incorrect.
By city planets, you mean cities?
Obviously the cities arent procedural. But thats not something to hail and praise, thats just normal. Its no more swept under the rug than “at least the guns shoot bullets at the enemies, and eventually it makes them die” is being swept under.
I’m just glad it’s been acknowledged now, so that people who aren’t us that can say “obviously” know that there’s more to it and it’s not “every single planet is exactly the same”.
Every single planet is the exact same.
The cities arent planets, as advertised for planetary exploration. Theyre cities. Preset prebuilt themed hubs meant for main quest check boxes and 2-5 side quests, with merchants.
When people say skyrim is filled with shit to do and explore, they dont mean “wowie zowie, those cities sure were designed by hand!” They mean that when they walk from the city to the quest waypoint, they bump into 50 different things to fuck around and do, and each is different and unique enough that it felt like you had 50 different things to do. And thats with the free criticism that skyrims dungeons were mildly samey and formulaic.
There isnt more to it. A technicality of the hub regions being on a planetary body doesnt change that the planets are all the same procedurally shuffled boxes.